In most hydraulic systems, no: 15W40 is engine oil, made for a different job than oil in a press. A hydraulic system needs an oil that lets go of water and air in the tank and has the right thickness for the pump; engine oil holds on to water, releases air more slowly and is usually thicker. The exception is a machine whose manual calls for engine oil in the hydraulics. Below, how to recognize it and what to do if 15W40 went in.

What does the oil do inside a hydraulic system?

The oil carries force from one point of the machine to another. Think of a syringe: you push the plunger on one side and the liquid comes out on the other, because a liquid barely lets itself be squeezed.

In a hydraulic system, the pump pushes the oil, and the oil pushes the cylinder, the part that closes the press or lifts the forklift fork. Valves choose the path.

Besides carrying force, the oil lubricates the pump and the valves, whose parts slide with clearances much thinner than a human hair, and it carries away heat and dirt.

The path is a closed circuit: the oil leaves the tank (also called the reservoir), passes through the pump, does its work, goes through the filter and returns. The oils that do this job are covered in the guide to types of hydraulic oil.

In the tank, the oil rests. Water that gets in through condensation or through the breather (the opening where the tank exchanges air with the surroundings) sinks to the bottom, because it is heavier; air bubbles rise. The pump draws oil through the suction line, a pipe that picks it up above the bottom, away from the water and the dirt.

Hydraulic oil circuit with the tank, pump, valve, cylinder and filter airtankwatersuction linepumpvalvecylinderfilter

Figure 1. The oil leaves the tank through the suction line, the pump pushes it to the cylinder, and it returns to the tank through the filter, below the oil level so it does not drag in air; in the tank, water sinks and air rises.

For this to work, the oil must let the water sink and the air rise. This is where engine oil starts to get in the way.

What is the difference between hydraulic oil and engine oil?

The main difference is in the additives: engine oil is made to hold dirt inside it, and hydraulic oil is made to release water and air in the tank.

Both are made the same way: almost all of it is base oil, the foundation of the lubricant, mineral or synthetic, and the rest is a small dose of additives, chemicals that give each oil its job. The two part ways in the additives, because the engine and the hydraulic system suffer different things.

The engine burns fuel, and combustion leaves soot, acids and water vapor in the oil. That is why engine oil carries plenty of detergent, which neutralizes the acids and cleans the parts, and dispersant, which keeps the soot scattered in the oil, in fine particles, until the oil change. It works like dish soap with grease in the rinse water.

These additives also hold water in the oil, in fine droplets. The oil turns milky, and this mixture is called an emulsion. In the engine this matters little, because the oil runs very hot and much of the water evaporates.

The hydraulic system burns nothing; its enemies are water, air and pump wear.

The most common type in industry is the antiwear hydraulic oil, which the German standard calls HLP. It is made to release water and air quickly and carries four additives:

  • rust inhibitor;

  • antioxidant, which slows the reaction of the oil with the oxygen in the air;

  • antiwear;

  • antifoam, which breaks the foam on the surface.

Engine oil also has antiwear and antifoam; what sets it apart from hydraulic oil is the heavy load of detergent and dispersant.

Characteristic15W40 engine oilHLP hydraulic oil
Main jobClean the engine and neutralize the acids from combustionCarry force and protect the pump
With waterHolds the water in fine droplets inside the oilLets the water sink to the bottom of the tank
With airReleases bubbles more slowlyReleases bubbles quickly
Working temperatureIn the sump, the engine's oil reservoir, very hot, close to the boiling point of waterWarm tank, where little water evaporates

For those who need the numbers: DIN 51524 has three parts: HL in part 1 (rust and oxidation inhibitors, no antiwear), HLP in part 2 and HVLP in part 3. HLP requires tests of water separation (demulsibility) and air release (DIN ISO 9120); ISO 6743-4 calls this type HM.

Engine oil follows another performance yardstick, the classification that the engine manual specifies. The hydraulic tank usually runs between 40 and 60 °C (104 to 140 °F), and the engine sump, close to 100 °C (212 °F).

With additives this different, it is easy to predict what happens when 15W40 ends up in the tank.

What happens if you put engine oil in the hydraulic system?

The machine keeps working for a while, and the damage shows up little by little, in the pump, the filter and the steel parts. The sequence usually goes like this:

  1. The detergent and the dispersant hold the water that enters the tank, which leads to an emulsion: milky oil, instead of water separated at the bottom.

  2. In the warm tank, almost none of this water evaporates, unlike in the engine, and it keeps circulating with the oil. This leads to rust on the rods and valves, faster pump wear and an oil that ages before its time.

  3. The antifoam in engine oil, silicone-based and dosed for the sump, can hold the finest bubbles inside the oil. It breaks the foam on the surface, but does not release the fine bubble from the middle of the oil. This lets air reach the pump.

  4. With water, some of the engine additives can form sludge, a soft paste, which leads the fine filter to clog ahead of schedule.

Air mixed into the oil inside the circuit has a name: aeration. Unlike oil, air can be compressed, and that is why the control feels "spongy" (the lever sinks and the cylinder is slow to respond), the pump makes noise and the oil heats up. Foam on the surface can also appear, especially when there is already water in the oil.

The clogged filter brings one more problem. It has a bypass valve, which opens when the filter clogs, so the oil does not stop flowing. With the valve open, the oil passes without being filtered and carries the dirt to the pump.

How this shows up in your plant:

  • milky oil in the tank sight glass;

  • foam on the surface;

  • noisy pump;

  • cylinder that moves in jerks or is slow to respond;

  • clogged-filter alarm soon after a change;

  • tank hotter than normal.

HLP hydraulic oil separates water and air in the tank; engine oil keeps both in the oil HLP hydraulic oilwater at the bottom, air on topEngine oilwater trapped in the oil,fine bubbles are slow to escape pumpfilterpumpfilter cloggingclean oil reaches the pumpwater and air reach the pump

Figure 2. In the tank, HLP hydraulic oil lets the water sink and the air rise; engine oil holds the water in fine droplets, is slow to release air and clogs the filter.

For those who need the numbers: DIN 51524 part 2 also requires the filterability test (ISO 13357), because water and additives that react with each other form residue that clogs a fine filter.

So far, the additives have been counted. Thickness is still missing.

Can you use 15W40 in place of the 68?

In most cases, no: in the warm tank, 15W40 is much thicker than 68, and the two numbers are not even measured at the same temperature.

Thickness has a name: viscosity, the resistance of an oil to flowing. Honey has a lot, water has little. Every oil thins when it heats up, like warmed honey, and that is why the thickness of two oils is compared at the same temperature.

The two numbers are measured at different temperatures (Figure 3):

  • The 68 is the ISO VG grade, the thickness at 40 °C (each grade is a narrow range around the number), close to the temperature of the hydraulic tank (see what ISO VG means).

  • 15W40 is an SAE grade, the yardstick for engine oil. The "15W" (W for winter) tells how the oil behaves at a cold start, and the "40" is the thickness with the engine hot, at 100 °C.

To work in both cold and heat, 15W40 is a multigrade: it carries a polymer, a very long molecule that slows the thinning when the oil heats up.

Now the calculation: at 40 °C, a 15W40 usually falls within or close to the ISO VG 100 range, about 1.5 times the thickness of the 68. That is a whole grade up, the same jump as putting the 68 where the manual calls for the 46 (see the difference between 46 and 68 hydraulic oil).

ISO VG and SAE grades measure thickness at different temperatures 40 °CISO VG: thicknessat 40 °C (the 68of the hydraulic)100 °CSAE: the 40 in 15W40is the thicknessat 100 °C Thickness scale at 40 °C (ISO VG ranges) 4668100 15W40 usually falls herethinnerthicker

Figure 3. ISO VG measures thickness at 40 °C and the SAE grade at 100 °C; brought to 40 °C, 15W40 usually falls in the ISO VG 100 range, one grade above the 68.

This extra thickness, together with the polymer, brings three effects:

  1. Cold start. The thick oil reaches the pump slowly. At the inlet, the pressure drops so much that the oil itself forms vapor bubbles, as if it were boiling without heat (water also boils below 100 °C at the top of a mountain). In the pressure zone, the part of the pump where the oil leaves under force, the vapor bubbles collapse all at once, and the blow, repeated thousands of times, pits the metal. This is cavitation.

  2. Slow response and more heat, because the pump spends more power pushing the thick oil.

  3. The polymer in engine oil can break. In the tight clearances of the pump and valves, some of the long molecules snap, and the oil thins with the hours of use in a way that is hard to predict. This polymer was chosen for the engine; the hydraulic pump shears more and calls for a more resistant polymer (Figure 4).

The engine oil polymer breaks in the pump clearance Engine oil: the polymer in the gap pump clearance whole strandsshort pieces the arrow shows the bar going down:the oil thins with hours of usehow much load the oilcan still carrydashed line:new-oil level

Figure 4. In the tight clearance of the pump, the long molecules of the engine oil polymer snap, and the oil thins with the hours of use; the dashed line marks the level of new oil, and the arrow shows the bar going down.

For the machine that works in the cold of the morning and the heat of the afternoon, the manual may call for the multigrade hydraulic oil, the HVLP, which carries a polymer chosen to withstand this stress in the pump. And even if the thickness of 15W40 matched, the additives would still be engine additives.

For those who need the numbers: under ISO 3448 (kinematic viscosity at 40 °C, in cSt, or centistokes, with 10% on each side of the midpoint), ISO VG 68 runs from 61.2 to 74.8 cSt, and ISO VG 100 from 90 to 110 cSt. Under SAE J300, SAE 40 runs from 12.5 to less than 16.3 cSt at 100 °C.

The viscosity at 40 °C is outside the SAE grade: public data sheets for mineral 15W40 generally show values between about 95 and 110 cSt. Part 3 of DIN 51524 includes a shear stability test, and ISO 6743-4 calls the HVLP an HV.

If engine oil brings so many problems, why do some machines call for it?

When does the manual allow engine oil in the hydraulic system?

When the manufacturer designed the system for it and wrote it in the manual. This happens in some mobile machines, such as excavators and loaders, and in tractors where the same oil circulates through the transmission, the wet brake (a brake that works bathed in oil) and the hydraulics.

In a tractor, the manual calls for a tractor-specific oil, a universal tractor fluid (UTTO), made to serve the transmission, the brake and the hydraulics at the same time; some also serve the engine, something an ordinary engine oil does not do.

In these cases, the pump, filter and tank were sized for that oil, and the manual gives the exact type and thickness of oil.

The rule is simple: the manual applies to the machine it describes. A tractor that accepts a tractor-specific oil does not make 15W40 suitable for the press in the plant.

Can you mix hydraulic oil with engine oil?

It is not advisable. A small amount of engine oil already brings detergent and dispersant to the whole tank, and the entire charge starts releasing water worse. Depending on the amount, the thickness of a 32, 46 or 68 hydraulic oil also goes beyond its grade.

The most common mistake is topping up the level with whatever oil was at hand in the shop. To avoid it:

  • identify the oil of each machine with a label on the tank;

  • keep the right oil near the machine;

  • top up with the same product that is already in the tank.

Hydraulic oils of different brands or types also call for confirmation from the supplier before mixing, because the additives can react with each other and form sludge.

I already put 15W40 in the hydraulic system: what now?

Stop topping up with 15W40 and plan the oil change. The longer the mixture runs, the more water and sludge build up in the tank and the filter. A safe sequence:

  1. Take a sample of the oil from the tank before draining, if there is doubt about how much 15W40 went in. The analysis estimates the proportion and shows whether there is already water in the oil.

  2. Drain with the oil still warm, right after the machine has worked, so the dirt comes out with it. Empty the tank, the lowest pipes and, when possible, the cylinders.

  3. Clean the bottom of the tank and replace the filters.

  4. Flush the circuit. As the Technical Team advises, a cleaning oil made for hydraulic systems, such as Supra FSH, or the new hydraulic oil itself circulates for a while and leaves carrying the residue.

  5. Drain the flushing oil, replace the filters again and fill with the hydraulic oil of the grade the manual calls for.

  6. Replace the filter once more after the first hours of work and check the new oil by analysis.

If only a little 15W40 went in and the machine ran for a short time, the analysis may show that draining and changing the filters is enough. The decision comes from the result, because the look of the oil in the sight glass is not enough to tell.

But what does the analysis look for?

How does Kelpen Oil identify engine oil in a hydraulic system?

By the chemical mark that engine oil leaves in the tank. It works like a fingerprint: engine oil has compounds that ordinary hydraulic oil does not, and the Kelpen Oil in-house laboratory in Arujá (SP) reads that mark in a sample.

The yardstick is the new oil that should be in the machine. The Kelpen Oil Technical Team compares the sample with it, the same way the types of oil analysis do in routine monitoring.

Many additives carry a chemical element in the molecule, and the laboratory can measure that element in the oil. The strongest signal is calcium, because a good part of the detergents in engine oil are made of calcium compounds. Boron, common in engine additives and rare in HLP, often helps confirm. Zinc and phosphorus weigh little, because they also appear in the antiwear additive of many hydraulic oils.

Another strong signal is the alkaline reserve, the ability of the oil to neutralize acids (abbreviated TBN, total base number). Engine oil has a lot, because it has to neutralize the acids from combustion; ordinary hydraulic oil has little.

When the sample shows calcium and alkaline reserve well above the new oil, it is a strong sign of engine oil, or of another oil with detergent, in the system. In a 32, 46 or 68 hydraulic oil, thickness above the new oil shows up when a lot of 15W40 went in.

There is one caveat: HLPD, a hydraulic oil with detergent for machines where water cannot be drained, also raises calcium and alkaline reserve. That is why the comparison holds against the new oil of the same product, and not against a fixed number.

Engine oil mark in the sample, compared with new oil compared with new oilnew oiltank sample calciumTBNthickness calciumTBNthickness reference: new oilrises whena lot went inTBN: total base number, the ability to neutralize acids

Figure 5. Each bar is compared with the new oil (the dashed line, the reference); the sample with engine oil shows much higher calcium and alkaline reserve; the thickness rises when a lot of 15W40 went in.

What we measureWhat it revealsStandard or method
Additive elements (calcium, boron, zinc and phosphorus)Calcium and, often, boron above the new oil point to an engine additive; zinc and phosphorus also appear in many hydraulic oils and serve as a cross-checkBy the NBR 14786 method (a Brazilian standard)
Total base number (TBN), the alkaline reserveA reserve above that of the new oil points to an oil with detergent, usually engine oil (HLPD and tractor oil also rise)NBR 5798 (a Brazilian standard)
Viscosity at 40 °C and at 100 °C, the thickness of the oil, and the viscosity index, which shows how much the oil thins as it heats upIn an HLP 32, 46 or 68, thickness above the new oil, when a lot of 15W40 went inASTM D7042 and NBR 14358 (a Brazilian standard)
Water in oilHow much water is in the oilCoulometric Karl Fischer, a method that measures even small amounts of water

The report can also measure demulsibility (NBR 14172), the ability to release water, and foaming characteristics (NBR 14235), how much foam the oil forms. The particle count (ISO 4406) completes the report and shows the cleanliness of the oil. What each test measures and how it is done is in the article on the lubricant laboratory tests. In-service oil analysis is a paid service.

Which oil should you use in the hydraulic system in each case?

The oil that the machine manual calls for; in most industrial equipment, it calls for HLP antiwear hydraulic oil.

If the machine is…UseWhy
Press, plastic injection molding machine, lathe, milling machine or other industrial machine with a hydraulic system (tank, pump and valves)HLP hydraulic oil in the ISO VG grade of the manual, such as those in the Supra AW line, which meets DIN 51524 part 2Releases water and air and protects the pump
Forklift, truck with crane or backhoe loader whose manual calls for hydraulic oilHydraulic oil in the grade of the manual, or HVLP, if the manual calls for itTank, pump and filter were designed for it
Tractor where transmission, wet brake and hydraulics use the same oilThe tractor-specific oil that the manual calls forThe same oil serves gear, brake and pump
Mobile machine whose manual specifies engine oil in the hydraulicsThe engine oil with the classification and thickness of the manualThe manufacturer sized the system for it
System that received 15W40 by mistakeAnalysis, draining, circuit flushing and a new charge of hydraulic oilThe mixture keeps the defects of engine oil

Kelpen Oil formulates the Supra AW line of HLP hydraulic oils, in the ISO VG grades in the name of each product, and the Technical Team confirms the grade for your machine. The other options are in industrial hydraulic oils.

Frequently asked questions

Can you use engine oil in a hydraulic jack? The right choice is the hydraulic oil that the jack manufacturer specifies, which is usually much thinner than engine oil. With 15W40, the jack rises and lowers slowly, especially in the cold, and the little water that condenses inside it stays trapped in the oil and, over time, favors rust inside.

What ISO VG is 15W40 equivalent to? There is no exact equivalence, because the two scales measure thickness at different temperatures. At the tank temperature, 40 °C, a 15W40 usually falls within or close to the ISO VG 100 range, and it is still engine oil, with engine additives.

Can you mix hydraulic oil with diesel fuel? It is not advisable. Diesel thins the oil, reduces pump protection and lowers the flash point, the lowest temperature at which the oil vapor briefly ignites on contact with a flame. This raises the fire risk near a leak. The circuit is cleaned with a cleaning oil made for hydraulics or with the new hydraulic oil itself.

Can ATF oil replace hydraulic oil? Where the equipment manual calls for ATF, yes. ATF is automatic transmission fluid, which carries additives for the gearbox clutches, and the criteria are in the article on how to choose ATF fluid.

Glossary

  • Emulsion: water trapped in the oil in fine droplets, which turns the oil milky.

  • HLP: antiwear hydraulic oil, with rust inhibitor, antioxidant and antifoam, made to release water and air; a class of DIN 51524 part 2.

  • Aeration: air mixed into the oil inside the circuit; it makes the control spongy, makes the pump noisy and heats the oil.

  • Viscosity: the thickness of the oil, its resistance to flowing; it drops when the oil heats up, so two oils are compared at the same temperature.

  • Multigrade: oil that works in cold and heat, generally thanks to a polymer that slows the thinning in the heat, like 15W40.

  • Cavitation: vapor bubbles of the oil itself, which form at the pump inlet and collapse all at once in the pressure zone, pitting the metal; air mixed into the oil, which also comes out at the suction, worsens the noise and the damage.

  • Alkaline reserve (TBN): the ability of the oil to neutralize acids; high in engine oil, low in ordinary hydraulic oil.

Talk to the Technical Team

The Kelpen Oil Technical Team evaluates the pump type, the pressure, the tank temperature and what the manual calls for, and confirms the right hydraulic oil. If the oil is already in use and a mixture is suspected, the Arujá (SP) laboratory performs the analysis of in-service oil, as a paid service.

Before topping up the level, look at three things: the label on the tank, the page of the manual that names the hydraulic oil and the look of the oil in the sight glass. If the oil is milky or foamy, take a sample before topping up. Send this article to whoever looks after the machines in your company.