Group 1 or Group 2? For oil that runs hot and stays in the machine for months, Group 2 with the right antioxidant; to dissolve additives or resins, or for very heavy grades, Group 1 or naphthenic (a family of petroleum oil that dissolves more than Group 2). Group 2 is a petroleum base oil cleaned with hydrogen and almost free of sulfur, and Kelpen Oil distributes both groups, all of it first-refined oil (made straight from crude oil).
One step back, for readers who arrive without this background: base oil is the liquid that makes up most of a lubricant; the rest is additives, ingredients added in small doses that give the oil a quality. The antioxidant is one of them: it slows the oil's reaction with oxygen in the air. The American Petroleum Institute (API), the United States oil industry association, sorts base oils into five groups, numbered 1 to 5, by what they contain. Groups 1 and 2 are the two this guide compares; Group 3 has a higher viscosity index (viscosity is the oil's resistance to flowing, and the index tells how much it changes with temperature: the higher the index, the less it changes), Group 5 gathers whatever does not fit the others, and Group 4 is not covered here.
The API writes the number in Roman numerals, I to V: Group II is the same as Group 2. The guide on what base oils are explains refining and the groups from the beginning.
Group 1 or Group 2: which base oil should you use?
It depends on what the oil has to do: lasting in heat, with the additive tuned for it, calls for Group 2; dissolving or being very heavy calls for Group 1 or naphthenic.
| If at your plant… | Use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| The oil runs hot and stays in the machine for months: hydraulic, turbine, compressor or circulating oil (which a pump keeps moving nonstop, including through the bearings, the supports where shafts turn) | Group 2, such as the Group II base oils (another way of writing Group 2) of the Kelpen Oil HBP-I line | Lasts longer in heat when it gets the right antioxidant |
| The product has to dissolve resin or additive, or soften rubber: oil-based paint, adhesive, oil for rubber compounds | In most cases, Group 1 or naphthenic, such as the Kelpen Oil HBN line; some rubbers accept Group 2 | Dissolves more |
| The oil has to be very heavy, as in the heaviest gear oils | Group 1 | Almost all very heavy mineral base oil comes from it |
| Your oil formula (the recipe of base oil and additives) uses Group 1, is approved and the oil does not age early | Keep the formula and only switch after testing | The switch affects the antioxidant, the additive and the seal (the rubber ring that holds the oil in the machine) |
Is Group 2 better than Group 1? Better for lasting in heat, with the right antioxidant; worse for dissolving. That is why the answer depends on which row of the table your plant is in.
Once the group is chosen, the next question is practical: whom to buy from and how to tell which group the oil that arrives belongs to.
Where to buy Group 2 base oil?
On the market since 1999, Kelpen Oil distributes base oils for lubricant producers: paraffinic Groups 1, 2 and 3, naphthenic, aromatic and mixed-base (the HPN line, which combines paraffinic and naphthenic). Paraffinic, naphthenic and aromatic are the three families of petroleum, according to the type of molecule that predominates, and the sections below explain each one. Group 2 is the HBP-I line, first-refined and hydrorefined (treated with hydrogen), in 20 L pails, 200 L drums, 1,000 L containers or bulk, with filling on demand.
Kelpen Oil has its own laboratory in Arujá (SP), with 25 standardized analyses and ISO 9001:2015 certification since 2003. To find out which checks make sense for the base oil you are about to buy, talk to the Kelpen Oil Technical Team. First, it is worth understanding what is different inside Group 2, so you can read the certificate with confidence.
What are Group 2 (Group II) base oils?
They are petroleum oils that went through a treatment with hydrogen and ended up with almost only one type of molecule, the saturated one.
A saturated molecule is one in which every carbon atom already has all the hydrogen it can hold. That is why it reacts with oxygen in the air much more slowly than the molecules the treatment reduces.
The molecules the treatment reduces are of two types. The aromatic has a six-carbon ring that still accepts more hydrogen (the benzene ring). The nitrogen compound is an impurity of petroleum.
The saturated molecule also oxidizes, but it fouls the oil less and lets the antioxidant work harder. The treatment also removes almost all the sulfur, an element that petroleum carries naturally, and this calls for care, as the section on heat shows.
Viscosity, the oil's resistance to flowing (honey has high viscosity, water has low), can be the same as in Group 1.
The viscosity index, which measures how much that viscosity changes with temperature, falls in the same API range (from 80 to under 120), usually closer to 120, the upper limit. A higher index is good: viscosity changes less when the temperature rises or falls.
For those who need the numbers: under API 1509, Annex E, Group 2 has 90% or more saturates, at most 0.03% sulfur (300 ppm, parts per million) and a viscosity index (VI) from 80 to under 120.
In Brazil, ANP Resolution 911/2022, from the National Petroleum Agency, uses the same numbers.
"Group II+" is a market name for Group 2 with a VI near 120; the API does not define this class.
What is the difference between Group 1 and Group 2?
The difference is in the cleaning. The starting crude may be the same, but Group 1 is washed with solvent and Group 2 goes through hydrogen.
The solvent dissolves the aromatics and carries them away, but only part of them and of the sulfur. The hydrogen transforms those molecules: almost no sulfur or nitrogen remains, and aromatics stay at 10% of the oil or less.
Since viscosity can be the same, the ISO VG grade, the number that gives the oil's viscosity at 40 °C (ISO is the international standards organization; ISO VG 68, ISO VG 150), does not reveal the group: both can have the same one.
| Criterion | Group 1 | Group 2 |
|---|---|---|
| How it is cleaned | With solvent | With hydrogen |
| Saturates (% by mass) | Usually below 90% | 90% or more |
| Sulfur (% by mass) | Usually above 0.03% (300 ppm) | Up to 0.03% (300 ppm) |
| Viscosity index | 80 to under 120 | 80 to under 120 |
| Oxidation resistance (the reaction with oxygen in the air) | Without additive, it can be as good or better, because part of the sulfur slows oxidation (the section on heat explains) | Better in the finished oil, with the right antioxidant |
| Solvency (ability to dissolve) | Higher | Lower |
| Color | Darker | Lighter |
For those who need the numbers: under the API, with a VI between 80 and under 120, a single criterion outside the limit (saturates below 90% or sulfur above 0.03%) is enough to make the base oil Group 1. With a VI below 80, it goes to Group 5, which gathers the base oils that do not fit the other groups, such as most naphthenics.
The oxidation and solvency rows of the table come from what hydrogen does inside the molecule.
What does hydrorefining change in the oil?
Hydrorefining, the treatment of oil with hydrogen, fixes the weakest points of the molecule: it removes sulfur and nitrogen and turns the aromatic ring into a saturated ring. Inside the refinery, the sequence is this:
The oil enters a reactor with hydrogen, under heat and pressure, and passes over a catalyst, a material that speeds up the reaction without being used up.
The sulfur and nitrogen come loose from the molecule and leave as gas (H₂S, hydrogen sulfide, and NH₃, ammonia), which is then separated from the oil. Keep this point in mind: part of that sulfur used to protect the oil.
The aromatic ring takes up hydrogen and becomes a saturated ring.
The oil comes out lighter in color.
Figure 1. Simplified hydrorefining: sulfur (S) and nitrogen (N) leave as gas (H₂S and NH₃), and the aromatic ring becomes a saturated ring.
For those who need the names: the typical Group 2 route combines hydrocracking (breaks large molecules), catalytic dewaxing (removes the wax that hardens in the cold) and hydrofinishing (the final finish of the oil); the other treats an already solvent-refined oil with hydrogen, severely. The intensity of the treatment decides whether the base oil ends up in Group 2 or Group 3.
Fewer weak points in the molecule suggest an oil that lasts longer. In the machine, the answer comes with a condition.
Does Group 2 last longer in heat?
It does, when it gets the right antioxidant. Without additive, Group 1 can last as long as Group 2, or longer.
Think of a cut apple: it darkens because it reacts with oxygen in the air, and faster on a hot day. Oil does the same, and this reaction is called oxidation. In equipment, it follows a chain:
Oxygen from the air reacts with the oil. Heat, the machine's copper and iron, and water speed it up. Aromatics and nitrogen compounds give way first; the saturated molecule also oxidizes, only more slowly.
The reaction first forms peroxide, an unstable product that speeds up its own oxidation, and then acids that make the oil acidic.
These products join into larger molecules, which the oil holds dissolved up to a point.
What goes past that point separates as sludge, a sticky mud, mostly where the oil cools, sticks to the valves and, with the heat of the following cycles, hardens like varnish.
The oil has to be changed early, a cost that does not show in the price per liter.
How this shows up at your plant: filters clogging early, a slow or sticking valve, oil darkening and acidity rising in the analysis.
Now the twist. Part of the sulfur compounds that stay in Group 1 breaks down this peroxide (the unstable product of step 2), which, if left loose, multiplies oxidation. It is an antioxidant that comes from the petroleum itself. That is why, without additive, a Group 1 can even last longer than a Group 2.
Group 2, with almost no sulfur, depends on the antioxidant that whoever formulates the oil adds. With the antioxidant chosen for it, it lasts longer than Group 1, because the saturated molecule gives the additive less work to do.
With the additive package (the set of additives in the formula) designed for Group 1, Group 2 can perform worse than Group 1, because the sulfur that package counted on is missing.
Figure 2. The same oxidation chain in three finished oils: Group 2 only reaches varnish later with the right antioxidant. The dot is the oil aging: whoever reaches varnish first lasts less.
For those who need the numbers: the acidity of oil in use is measured by the total acid number, the TAN (NBR 14448). Its rise in the analysis is the sign that the chain has already advanced.
With the right antioxidant, Group 2 wins at lasting in heat; Group 1 has the edge on two other fronts.
What does Group 1 do better than Group 2?
Two things: it dissolves better and it reaches much heavier grades.
It dissolves better
This quality has a name: solvency, the ability to dissolve. The rule "like dissolves like" applies, the same one that makes grease come off with oil and not with water. Aromatics resemble resin and many additives, and so they dissolve them. Group 2, with few aromatics, dissolves less.
In the additive. An additive that dissolved in Group 1 may turn cloudy in Group 2, especially in the cold.
In rubber. Rubber takes in oil to become soft and easy to mold: the plasticizer softens and the extender adds bulk to the mix. For this the oil has to blend well with the mix, and each rubber calls for an oil similar to itself.
Tire rubber (the synthetic SBR, styrene-butadiene, and BR, butadiene) pairs with aromatic or naphthenic oil. The synthetic rubber used in profiles and hoses (EPDM) pairs with paraffinic oil, the family of Groups 1, 2 and 3, and there Group 2 also works.
Because of solvency, the plasticizer and extender for most rubbers, oil-based paint and adhesive stay with Group 1, naphthenic or aromatic; the families are covered in the post on paraffinic, naphthenic or aromatic oil.
In the seal. The seal is the rubber ring that holds the oil inside the machine. A nitrile rubber seal (a type of synthetic rubber resistant to oil), the most common in hydraulic systems, swells a little in oil with aromatics, and the machine was set up for that swelling.
If that seal spent years that way in Group 1, it may shrink and harden after the change, and the leak appears. A fluorinated rubber seal, another type of synthetic rubber, hardly changes.
In the oxidation residue. With the right antioxidant, Group 2 forms less residue, but holds less of it dissolved. That is why the additive package also has to keep it in suspension, away from the valve (step 4 of the oxidation chain: sludge and varnish).
For those who need the numbers: solvency is measured by the aniline point (ASTM D611 method, from the American standards body for testing methods), the temperature at which the oil and aniline, a laboratory solvent, mix completely. The higher the aniline point, the less the oil dissolves. At the same viscosity grade, Group 2 usually has a higher aniline point than Group 1.
It reaches heavier grades
Group 1 is almost the only source of bright stock, the heaviest mineral base oil, which still goes into the highest-viscosity gear oils.
Figure 3. What each group gains: Group 2 lasts in heat, with the right antioxidant; Group 1 dissolves the additive better.
When does switching from Group 1 to Group 2 pay off?
It pays off where heat, air and time in use rule, and the formula can be adjusted to Group 2.
The typical cases are severe-cycle hydraulic oil (the guide to types of hydraulic oil shows the classes), circulating and turbine oil, compressor oil and industrial gear oil in the medium grades.
It does not pay off where solvency or a very heavy grade is the requirement. Switching just to switch, in those cases, means changing the formula and testing again for a property the application does not use.
Outside industrial lubrication, those who formulate engine oil also use Group 2 and Group 3. The engine gets very hot, and a base oil that evaporates less (loses less oil to heat) keeps level and viscosity; with the additive package tuned for it, it lasts longer. Kelpen Oil distributes Group 2 and Group 3 base oils for this formulation.
When it pays off, the switch calls for four checks before going into production:
Tune the antioxidant to the low-sulfur base oil.
Test whether the additive stays dissolved, also in the cold.
Check the equipment's seal.
Repeat on the finished oil the oxidation test, viscosity, water separation, release of air trapped in the oil and foam.
For those who need the numbers: the oxidation tests (which age the oil by force, in the laboratory, to see how much it resists) most used for turbine and hydraulic oil are the TOST (ASTM D943 or ISO 4263-1, with heated oil, oxygen, water, iron and copper) and the RPVOT (ASTM D2272). Seal compatibility follows ISO 6072. For water separation, air release and foam, the standards are, in that order, ASTM D1401, ASTM D3427 and ASTM D892.
The criterion, in short: lasting in heat, with the antioxidant tuned, calls for Group 2; solvency and a very heavy grade call for Group 1 or naphthenic. What remains is knowing whether the base oil reaching your plant really is Group 2.
How can you tell which group the base oil you buy belongs to?
By the quality certificate, the document with the analysis results that, under ANP Resolution 911/2022, accompanies the load of base oil sold to those who make lubricant. Three numbers on it decide the group:
Sulfur: usually given in ppm. Group 2 must show 300 ppm or less.
Saturates: as a percentage, by ASTM D2007. It is the API criterion, and Group 2 needs 90% or more.
Viscosity index: from 80 to under 120, Group 1 or 2; with 120 or more and the other two limits met, Group 3; below 80, Group 5, like most naphthenics.
Figure 4. The three fields of the quality certificate that decide the group, each with the API 1509 limit for Group 2.
The trade name is not enough. "SN 150" (traditional name of solvent-refined base oil, with the viscosity at the end) indicates the refining route and the viscosity, but does not guarantee the group. Neither does "hydrotreated" guarantee Group 2: a lot of Group 1 goes through a light hydrogen bath just to lighten its color.
What analyses does a laboratory run to check a base oil?
The certificate carries the producer's numbers. To check the oil that arrived, the Arujá laboratory has these on its list of 25 analyses, among others. In each row, ASTM is the American standards body for testing methods and NBR is the Brazilian standard.
| What we measure | What it reveals | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| Viscosity at 40 °C and 100 °C (the oil's resistance to flowing) | Whether the viscosity matches the order; both values go into the viscosity index calculation | ASTM D7042 |
| Viscosity index (how much viscosity changes with temperature) | Whether the oil stays in the range of 80 to under 120 (Groups 1 and 2) or reaches 120 or more (Group 3) | NBR 14358 |
| Aniline point (the temperature at which the oil mixes completely with aniline, a laboratory solvent) | Shows how much the oil dissolves: the higher it is, the less the oil dissolves | ASTM D611 |
| Flash point | The temperature at which the oil's vapor ignites; a light fraction (the part that evaporates easily) makes the oil catch fire sooner | NBR 11341 |
| Sulfur, calcium, phosphorus and zinc (X-ray fluorescence, which reads the elements without touching the sample) | Whether the sulfur matches the group: Group 2 has up to 0.03%; more than that points to Group 1 | ASTM D6481 |
| Density | The mass of the oil per liter; a sample that departs from the previous lot may be mixed | Digital density meter (DMA 4501) |
| Infrared (infrared light passed through the sample) | The oil's chemical fingerprint, compared with that of a previous sample; shows mixing or contamination | ASTM E2412 (compares with the previous sample) |
The method for each analysis is in the post on laboratory tests. To find out which of them Kelpen Oil runs on the base oil it distributes, talk to the Technical Team.
Frequently asked questions
Is Group 2 better than Group 1? It depends on the use. With the right antioxidant, Group 2 lasts longer in heat; Group 1 dissolves more and reaches heavier grades.
Is Group 2 base oil mineral or synthetic? Mineral: hydrorefining changes the molecule without changing the origin, and the ANP counts Group 2 among mineral base oils. Group 3 also almost always comes from petroleum, but the ANP counts it as a synthetic base oil in its lubricant registration rule; that is why, when buying, it is worth asking for the API group.
Can you mix Group 1 and Group 2 base oil? Yes. Both are mineral oils and blend well. The mix ends up with properties in between and only stays Group 2 if the certificate of the mix meets the limits.
Are Group 2 and C2 the same thing? No. The group classifies the base oil, the raw material; C2 and C3 are ACEA categories, the association of European automakers, for finished engine oil. A C3 oil can be made with Group 2 or 3 base oil.
What does SN oil mean? SN comes from "solvent neutral", the traditional name of solvent-refined base oil, followed by the viscosity (SN 150, SN 500), and it is usually Group 1. Group 2 usually comes as "N" (150N, 600N), but some people use "SN" loosely; the certificate confirms.
Glossary
Base oil: most of a lubricant, before additives.
Hydrorefining: treatment with hydrogen that removes sulfur and nitrogen and turns aromatics into saturates.
Saturated: a molecule with all the hydrogen it can hold; it oxidizes more slowly than the aromatic and lets the antioxidant work harder.
Oxidation: reaction of the oil with oxygen in the air, sped up by heat; it leads to acidity, sludge and varnish.
Antioxidant: additive that slows oxidation; in Group 2, it has to be chosen for the low-sulfur base oil.
Solvency: the oil's ability to dissolve additive and resin; the aniline point gives an idea of it.
Naphthenic: family of petroleum base oil separate from the paraffinics (Groups 1, 2 and 3); it dissolves more than Group 2 and, under the API, most of it falls in Group 5.
Talk to the Technical Team
Before the switch, the Kelpen Oil Technical Team evaluates the application, the viscosity, the additive package, the equipment's seal and the stability requirement, and confirms the right product. To find out what the base oil you already use is, from any origin, the Arujá (SP) laboratory runs the oil analysis, as a paid service. Save this article for your next base oil quote or send it to whoever formulates at your company.




